$202.98 -1.05%
ETH · 66w

Gnosis Is Now A Defunct Project. Delphi Goes For The Throat

Wealth Distribution and Why It Matters

Every so often, a statement will be made which puts everything into perspective. An excellent example of this is this comment from the Gnosis AMA on Reddit a few months ago, made by Martin Köppelmann (the co-founder and CEO of Gnosis):

“Augur could not call itself a decentralized prediction market if they would control >50% of their tokens. However — Gnosis is decentralized regardless of the distribution of tokens. Even if we would keep 100% of the tokens and not sell any we could not interfere with markets on Gnosis. Gnosis is decentralized because it runs on Ethereum.”

If this quote seems like a boldfaced dismissal of a serious concern, that’s because that’s exactly what it is. Just because something “runs on Ethereum” does not automatically make it meaningfully decentralized (in fact, if that were the only criteria that needed to be met, then Augur would qualify just as well as Gnosis). Yet here we have the creator himself saying that he would be perfectly fine calling Gnosis “decentralized” even if he personally controlled 100% of the tokens and no one else were able to use the system in any way whatsoever.

The worst part is, the above claim is false. The distribution of GNO tokens matters very much in the Gnosis protocol, and if the majority of the tokens are concentrated into too few hands, it introduces critical vulnerabilities into the system (and completely prevents the model from being sustainable in the long term).

Let’s dive into why.

Poisonous Token Incentives and Perpetual Profit Machines

Gnosis is designed so that users of the platform can pay fees in three different tokens: WIZ, BTC, or ETH. WIZ tokens are Gnosis-specific, and are pegged to represent $1 of value (though this peg isn’t sustainable in Gnosis, which we’ll explain further momentarily). A fee payment with WIZ is the most straightforward of the three options, and these fees would not be critically vulner...

Continue on
Recent news
ETH -1.05% · · 3h

Raiden Network Web Application Demo

Get started with the web application by installing Raiden: Then fire up the web a...
ETH -1.05% · · 6h

$100 Trillion - Multicoin Capital

Last Friday, Yale, the iconic long-term investor that other endowments look to for guidance, made a historic investment in two funds dedicated to crypto, signaling to many that institutional floodgate...
ETH -1.05% · · 15h

Vinay Gupta expands on Mattereum

Momentous times at @Mattereum. We've been digging into the legals underpinning, well, _everything_ for a year, and we hit the gold three months ago: a completely new approach to smart contract legal e...
ETH -1.05% · · 17h

From BlackRock to Blockchain

In October 2007, months before the dramatic breakdown of our global financial system and the beginning of the “Great Recession,” I joined the BlackRock Financial Markets Advisory Group. The team…